Similarly, in Schofield v. Schofield, the Superior Court of Pennsylvania validated a cousin marriage legally celebrated elsewhere because it found no basis to consider such a marriage harmful and necessary to be voided.22951 Pa. Super. Ariz. Rev. First cousins once-removed and half-cousins are not allowed to marry, either. See infra Section I.C.5. a particular identity the states have weaponized160Weaponized is used intentionally here: scholars have traced the emergence of the cousin bans to the surging racial and ethnic discrimination in the closing decades of the nineteenth and the early twentieth centuries, the period in which nearly all the bans were introduced; with first-cousin marriages more popular among minorities, they were a natural target for animus-motivated restrictive regulations. As of January 2020, the Peang-Lees were expecting their first child, increasing their risk of being charged under Utahs incest statute. First cousins once-removed, cousins through adoption and half-cousins can marry in Nebraska. The same thing happens with the couple. The cousin bans rely on the bio-genetic concern even more so than incest regulations generally, as the bans emerged only in the period where bio-evolutionary scientists began seriously considering whether consanguinity is tied to childrens outcomes. This Section will demonstrate that by placing direct prohibitions or severe limitations on the liberty of a particular identity group to exercise this fundamental right, the bans trigger a heightened, stringent form of scrutiny.146See infra Section II.A. 3. . In Meister, the Court held the states power would not be presumed to curtail traditional forms and methods of marriage because of the great importance of the right to the individual.124Id. However, two years later, in 1971, the Criminal Law Amendment Act repealed section 146 of the Criminal Code, which prohibited marriage by common-law spouses. Regardless, Canadian law supports it as long as it is not a marriage between two direct relatives like a father and daughter or brother and sister. Professor Bittles of the Murdoch University Centre for Comparative Genomics is the leading expert in the study of consanguineous marriage. . Typically, fundamental rights automatically trigger strict scrutiny.130See, e.g., Reno v. Flores, 507 U.S. 292, 30102 (1993); see also Wardle, supra note 63, at 325 n.156. No one would want to have a child with disabilities. According to one study published in 2014, 2050 percent of marriages or more are consanguineous in North and Sub-Saharan Africa, the Middle East, and West, Central, and South Asia, regions with a collective population of over a billion persons. Stat. President Franklin Delano Roosevelt and his wife, Eleanor, were fifth cousins once removed, while notable figures Albert Einstein and Charles Darwin married their own first cousins. at 2627; Ottenheimer, supra note 19, at 5859. You people might share a somewhat similar genetic material, but it is not that problematic. Apart from Legal Inquirer, he is a serial entrepreneur, and has founded multiple successful companies in different industries. Marriages perceived central role in two critical spheresensuring social order and civilizations continuityhas traditionally been relied upon to justify state-crafted, localized approaches to matters of family life. Ann. However many scientists disagree over how large of a role genetics plays in disease etiology. . . 1 (2018) (arguing against the hegemony marriage enjoys over nonmarriage relationships in America), with Ryan T. Anderson, Marriage: What It Is, Why It Matters, and the Consequences of Redefining It, Heritage Found. According to this act, a first cousin couple must meet the following criteria to marry one another legally. Alan H. Bittles, Consanguinity in Context 2940 (2012). However, a sanction proving the infertility of the people involved is needed to get married. consanguineous mating constitutes a threat to this institution. But can we tag this bond as love? Webincluding termination and the denial of legal representation and indemnification by the State in the event that a lawsuit is filed having a connection with a personal relationship. We are all clear that it does not understand gender either. Following are the few types of cousins one could have: It is common for people to know their first cousin. at 54445 (Stone, C.J., concurring) (finding neither common knowledge [n]or experience, [nor] scientific investigation, has given assurance that the criminal tendencies of any class of habitual offenders are universally or even generally inheritable (footnote omitted)); id. It is illegal in Mississippi for first cousins to marry, have sexual relations or cohabitate. . Cousin marriage has been traced back through history to biblical times and is still practiced in many countries around the world. They must have resided in Canada for not less than three years. Cousin marriage is definitely not a religious thing. But see State v. Nakashima, 114 P. 894, 896 (Wash. 1911) (quoting State v. Brown, 23 N.E. 1.101, 2.004, 6.201 (West 2021); Tex. In State v. Couvillion, the Supreme Court of Louisiana relied on the fact that first cousins share a remote relationship, unlike nuclear relatives, in upholding a marriage despite a cousin ban.21542 So. WebPeople who are above the age of 65 years or 55 years are permitted to marry their cousins. Id. It is a throwaway comment in a paragraph whose core purpose, i.e., outlining the federalism principle behind varying state marriage laws, was not relied upon for Windsors holding, which utilized instead a rational basis review with bite/animus analysis. : Obergefell v. Hodges, 129 Harv. So what happens when what the heart wants is generally considered taboo? Rev. This taboo is deap seated in cultures due to the rules and laws against incest. As the Constitution endures, persons in every generation can invoke its principles in their own search for greater freedom. (internal citations omitted)), Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644, 672 (2015) ([W]hen that sincere, personal opposition becomes enacted law and public policy, the necessary consequence is to put the imprimatur of the State itself on an exclusion that soon demeans or stigmatizes those whose own liberty is then denied.). Some people are against marriages between relatives for ethical or physiological reasons, but some cultures support the idea. Griswold hinted at something more.109Griswold, 381 U.S. at 48586. King World Productions Inc. 2023 Inside Edition Inc. and CBS interactive Inc., Paramount companies. That question has already been taken up by a host of law review articles and student notes. psychological trauma, and social stigmatization, for those in the relationship and their families.211Metteer, supra note 18, at 27478; Richard P. Kluft, Ramifications of Incest, Psychiatric Times (Jan. 12, 2011), https://www.psychiatrictimes.com/sexual-offenses/ramifications-incest [https://perma.cc/M4AC-KEEV] (asserting that sex between relatives often leads to traumatic bonding,. Following the introduction of the cousin bans, courts have continued to recognize cousin marriage as innocuous.227See generally Storke, supra note 55, at 49397. Both parents should have the gene for these diseases to appear in a child. hng ti cc trang mng x hi hay gian hng trc tuyn trn cc nn tng bn hng Justice Potter Stewarts Zablocki concurrence criticized the majority exactly for this unusual approach to equal protection doctrine.89Zablocki, 434 U.S. at 39196 (Stewart, J., concurring) (approving of the lower courts approach to the right to marry as a due process issue, and insisting, [t]he problem in this case is not one of discriminatory classifications, but of unwarranted encroachment upon a constitutionally protected freedom, as it conflicts with the liberty promise). On the other hand, there are many cases of historical figures who had descendants in consanguineous marriages; like Charles Darwin, married to his cousin, Thomas Jefferson, Roosevelt Thus, the experts assure us that two primary cousins inherit approximately an average of 25% of the genetic material from each parent, so they share an average of 12.5% of their genome, compared to 50% shared by two brothers. Skinner v. Oklahoma directly linked the right to marry with a fundamental right to reproduce.105316 U.S. 535 (1942); see also Wardle, supra note 63, at 299300. McDonnell, supra note 17, at 350 n.93 (counting eight states with such prohibitions, as that article was published prior to Texass enactment of its regulation in 2010). In some cases, the legal system allows for divorce if one partner commits adultery, so this could be an option for someone who feels uncomfortable with their cousin but needs to keep their relationship secret for their own good. Yet, the majority decisions in Lawrence286539 U.S. at 57179 (majority opinion) (Our obligation is to define the liberty of all, not to mandate our own moral code. trong vic xy dng website. Similarly, sexual orientation was not clearly categorized as a protected class in Obergefell;157Carl H. Esbeck, A Post-Obergefell America: Is a Season of Legal and Social Strife Inevitable?, 11 Christian Law. As far as the legality of sibling marriage is concerned, it is not legal in any country or state. Yes, you can marry your adopted sibling in the USA, as long as you are not related beyond a fourth degree. In the past, some provinces, such as Alberta and Ontario, had similar legislation against marriage between first cousins, but the laws were eventually repealed. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. 12.34 (West 2021); Washington v. Glucksberg, 521 U.S. 702, 720721 (1997) (listing the right to marry among a limited number of well-established unenumerated rights); Washington v. Harper, 494 U.S. 210, 224 (1990) (reaffirming without elaboration that the right to marry. However, a sanction proving the They must have completed high school or its equivalent. L. Inst. . But if we talk for example of a 12-year-old and a 5-year-old, it is a different story. may have subtle, farreaching [sic] and devastating effects. 457:2 (2021); N.C. Gen. Stat. First cousins in New York are allowed to marry, as well as live together and have sexual relations. Is it OK to have a relationship with your second cousin? of Loughmiller, 629 P.2d 156 (Kan. 1981); cf. According to the National Conference of State Legislatures website (NCSL), it is legal for first cousins to get married in 21 states across the United States of America. Such counseling helps advise individuals and families affected by or at risk of genetic disorders to help them understand and adapt to the medical, psychological and familial implications of genetic contributions to disease. (Under our Constitution, the freedom to marry or not marry, a person of another race resides with the individual and cannot be infringed by the State.); see also Grossman & Friedman, supra note 51, at 3738. L. 21 (1993) (analyzing relationships between step-relatives). Those that prohibit first-cousin marriage without exceptionthe majority approach166See supra notes 4445 and accompanying text.are directly analogous to the Loving or Obergefell statutes: the state places an identity, be it race,167The Virginia statute in Loving provided that it was a felony for any white person [to] intermarry with a colored person, or any colored person [to] intermarry with a white person. Loving, 388 U.S. at 4 (quoting Racial Integrity Act of 1924, Va. Code Ann. In at 38384; Grossman & Friedman, supra note 51, at 39. First cousins in North Carolina can marry, so long as they are not double first cousins. . In Califano v. Jobst,78434 U.S. 47 (1977). There are no curtailments on this. 31-11-8-3 (West 2021); Iowa Code Ann. This would include a cousin once removed or second cousin twice removed. However, some countries still pose conditions on cousins marrying each other to avoid producing a baby with genetic disorders. Mr. Staehlin plans to leave $10,000 to each of his siblings and his mother. For instance, the alleged affinity Native Americans had for cousin marriage was cited by cousin ban agitators to advance their cause.234Ottenheimer, supra note 19, at 50. Robert Graboyes, DNA and the Shadowland of Ethics, Newsday (Apr. . 7 c. 47 (lifting longstanding prohibition on marriage between a man and his sister-in-law); see also infra note 27 and accompanying text. .); Maynard v. Hill, 125 U.S. 190, 211 (1888) (without marriage there would be neither civilization nor progress); see Jill Lepore, To Have and To Hold, New Yorker (May 18, 2015), https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/05/25/to-have-and-to-hold [https://perma.cc/98JW-WJG4] (discussing the modern effort to disassociate marriage and sex from reproduction in constitutional analysis). But why is it so? Ann. 2000), some House members expressed concerns over the discriminatory tenor of the law and the mocking discussion of such relationships on the floor. And developing sexual relations with them would not harm the future generation in any way. Due to fear of developing genetically disabled people, the countries and states do not allow people with blood relations and genetic relations to marry each other. See supra notes 174175 and accompanying text. The dynamic of our constitutional system is that individuals need not await legislative action before asserting a fundamental right.). . Maynard v. Hill, 125 U.S. 190, 205 (1888) (Marriage, as creating the most important relation in life, as having more to do with the morals and civilization of a people than any other institution, has always been subject to the control of the legislature.). Connecticut also allows first cousins to have sexual relations and cohabitate. . 25-101(b) (first cousins may not marry unless both partners are over sixty-five, or they present proof to a judge of one partners infertility); 750 Ill. Comp. WebFirst cousin marriage in its usual and dating my hubby wasn't just 7 years to marry and relationships so. As per Canadian laws, if children in a marriage are under 18 years old and have been lawfully adopted by their parents, marriage between cousins is prohibited but not illegal. It is because first cousins are not that closely related. In some states, such as Maryland, New York, Pennsylvania, and Washington, former spouses can be forced to divorce if one partner later marries someone else. 30-1-1(2); Wis. Stat. See, e.g., Turner, 482 U.S. at 96 (protecting the right to marry of inmates, most [of whom] eventually will be released). This would not be legal marriage contract but rather an agreement between two people. Rather, they have been primarily motivated by an independent concern for dissuading evasion of the law. ti 41, 4445 (2015) (arguing states must get out of the business of marriage). You can do so in the Constitution State. 561, 56165 (1994) [hereinafter Bittles, Role and Significance]; accord Adam Kuper, Changing the Subject: About Cousin Marriage, Among Other Things, 14 J. Royal Anthropological Inst. . Its like that phrase that is often said: Better to be fighting with others than with yourself.. rather, a gender-based classification was struck down based on an equal dignity doctrine that all persons enjoy the constitutionally-protected autonomy to pursue a personally satisfying marriage.158Yoshino, supra note 93, at 17179; Tribe, supra note 95, at 17, 2332. 801, 801 (2013) (Each disorder is individually rare, but their cumulative incidence is relatively high, around 1 in 1500 to 1 in 5000 live births.); Edinen Asuka, Donald Jeanmonod & Rebecca Jeanmonod, Inborn Errors of Metabolism, Natl Ctr. All states impose limitations or restrictions on marriage to some extent,120See generally Shane R. Martins, Consistency Is Key: To Preserve Legislative Intent the IRS Must Afford Legal Recognition to Non-Marital Relationships in a Post-DOMA World, 15 Marq. (Md. In this sense, the researcher gives us the information: Inbreeding relationships have been very popular in some cultures; even today it is estimated that they could account for up to 10% of relationships worldwide, although in Europe the value would be much lower (1-3%). [W]e are persuaded to [uphold the marriage].); see also Storke, supra note 55, at 49397 (discussing conflict of laws issues arising with conflicting cousin marriage regulations); see generally P. H. Vartanian, Annotation, Recognition of Foreign Marriage as Affected by Policy in Respect of Incestuous Marriages, 117 A.L.R. Here are a few countries which permit family members to marry each other: In Portugal, marriage between siblings is not allowed as they are closely related. . Siblings cannot marry each other as they are blood relatives and this can have dire consequences. See Deceased Wifes Sisters Marriage Act, 1907, 7 Edw. 5/212 (West 2021); Ind. Nabeel Ahmad is the founder and editor-in-chief of Legal Inquirer. How Common Are Cousin Marriages in Canada? They are Arizona, Illinois, Indiana, Utah, Wisconsin, and Maine. L.J. tit. In addition to criminalizing incest itself (under section 155), this act prohibited marriage between first cousins. The courts have found greater value in showing interstate comity by recognizing marriages licensed abroad than in enforcing the cousin bans,279Storke, supra note 55, at 49397; Loughmiller, 629 P.2d at 158 (The general rule with regard to the recognition of marriages solemnized elsewhere is that if the marriage is valid where contracted, it is valid everywhere.). Adopted cousin relationship (how to inform the family). 19-A, 701(2)(B) (2021); Mich. Comp. 2008). Regardless, there is a possibility of first cousins getting married in Canada. Rev. Some states also permit adopted siblings and step-siblings to marry each other as they are not blood relatives. First, the state plays a central role in regulating marriage.61Brian H. Bix, State Interests in Marriage, Interstate Recognition, and Choice of Law, 38 Creighton L. Rev. 1948)); Loving, 388 U.S. at 12. Ann. Second-cousin marriages were once common throughout Europe and North America. are reminiscent of the prior permission provisions the Court invalidated in Zablocki172Zablocki v. Redhail, 434 U.S. 374 (1978) (requiring noncustodial parent receive court assent prior to marrying). As you will notice, most states permit first cousin marriages. .); Alan H. Bittles, The Role and Significance of Consanguinity as a Demographic Variable, 20 Population & Dev. Also, they are two generations away from the shared grandparents. Consanguinity is understood as the relationship established between two people who share a close common relative. You should also ask yourself if you want to marry your cousin or not. Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1, 12 (1967) (The freedom to marry has long been recognized as one of the vital personal rights essential to the orderly pursuit of happiness by free men.); Goodridge v. Dept of Pub. The fundamental nature of the marriage relationship itself74Id. Cf. was key to the Courts reasoning.75Id. All in all, marrying your cousin or half-sibling will largely depend on the laws where you live and personal and/or cultural beliefs. The Maine statute may be the narrowest in scope251The five states that permit marriage where the couple is old or infertile may already be in active violation of the right to privacy. Metteer, supra note 18, at 26970 (discussing the Turner Courts determination that prison officials do need the autonomy to take action they deem necessary for security purposesan administrative flexibility absent in any of the cousin bans). For a detailed discussion of the fundamental right to marry, see. However, it is worth noting that some regions and religious groups in Japan may have their own restrictions on cousin marriage. To be very clear, a prohibition on marriage does not de facto make such a relationship incestuous. Id. . It is important to ensure that the child produced by the first cousins does not have genetic disorders. Ann. If you dont act consistently, you wont be consistent regardless of how successful you are. Their inclusion should not be taken as an endorsement of those eugenicist views. First, the bans are overinclusive, as they cover the roughly ninety-three percent of cousin couples who will have children without any risk of defect.242Grossman, supra note 18.. Second, they are underinclusive on two fronts: (1) they prohibit marriage, which may deter but surely does not prevent children from being born to first cousins,243See generally George A. Akerlof & Janet L.Yellen, An Analysis of Out-of-Wedlock Births in the United States, Brookings Inst. Like the anti-miscegenation laws, the cousin bans persist under the guise of maintaining social progress, but function as a pretext for a machine of discrimination.235See id. Me. 2d 731, 748 (La. to protect society at large from the effects of incest, rather than to protect the individuals involved from the effects of their incestuous liaisons.). . . In those cases, the circumscribed identitiespersons delinquent in child support payments and inmates, respectivelywere not by the statutes terms absolutely barred from marriage, but the statutes tied the classified identities access to marriage on obtaining dispensations from designated state officials.174Compare Zablocki, 434 U.S. at 37578 (permitting a noncustodial parent to marry after first obtaining a court order granting permission to marry), with Turner, 482 U.S. at 96 (permitting inmates to marry provided the prison superintendent has approved the marriage after finding that there are compelling reasons for doing so). at 69798 (Roberts, C.J., dissenting). The right to marry includes matters of personal significance and fulfillment, independent of a desire or ability to procreate.257See supra notes 112119 and accompanying text. 765.03(1) (first cousins may not marry unless the female is over fifty-five or an affidavit signed by a medical professional is produced indicating either partner is permanently sterile); Me. According to his research, he states that almost 10.4% of the global population are married to a close relative or are the offspring of such a marriage. Rev. Yolanda Dwyer is a relationship and communication expert. Also, it is likely that in some communities, married cousins may have more children compared to normal unrelated couples. Kenji Yoshino, Why the Court Can Strike Down Marriage Restrictions Under Rational-Basis Review, SCOTUS Blog (Aug. 23, 2011, 8:38 AM), https://www.scotusblog.com/2011/08/why-the-court-can-strike-down-marriage-restrictions-under-rational-basis-review [https://perma.cc/R3L6-558F] (suggesting it is the animus being expressed toward the class more than the nature of the right itself that primarily guided the heightened inquiry in certain marriage cases). We and our partners use cookies to Store and/or access information on a device. In fact, almost half of the states in America allow cousin marriages to take place legally. thng Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1 (1967) (striking down anti-miscegenation laws). Cousin marriage has been traced back through history to biblical times and is still practiced in many countries around the (Sept. 23, 2015), 2015 Anthony M. Kennedy Lecture, in 20 Lewis & Clark L. Rev. They are two individuals having different sets of biological parents, united by the relationship between their parents. Ct. App. [is] a right protected by the Due Process Clause); see also Metteer, supra note 18, at 265. See supra Section II.B.3. The theory claims that marriage between non-kin, or exogamy, promotes social cohesion by forcing intergroup alliances, increasing humanitys ability to survive, while in-marriage, or endogamy, reinforces humans natural tribalism.223Ottenheimer, supra note 19, at 13444. This Article will examine the constitutionality of these stubborn prohibitions on first-cousin marriage in light of the fundamental right to marry as articulated by the Supreme Court in a series of decisions over the last century.16For a detailed discussion of the fundamental right to marry, see infra Section I.C. The third justification proposes first-cousin marriage visits harm upon society at large.222Moore, supra note 18, at 147; see also Metteer, supra note 18 at 273 (The states interests are. 451.020, 451.115 (West 2021); Mont. The five states that permit marriage where the couple is old or infertile may already be in active violation of the right to privacy. Stat. . They don't have any of the other requirements to be married under the law including age difference if one of them is a minor. .). Ann. Use your conscience and find an answer to what you feel. tit. Med. To view the purposes they believe they have legitimate interest for, or to object to this data processing use the vendor list link below. As having the same parents, you share the same genes. Code Ann. Code Ann. If the offspring of a union. Should the states be intervening in the matter as private as marriage? . Lawrence v. Texas, 539 U.S. 558, 560, 567, 575 (2003). Second-cousin marriages were once common throughout Europe and North America. First cousins can cohabitate or have sexual relations. Stat. credits the Obergefell Court with introducing an artistic approach to due process and equal protection, infusing the former with a concern that liberties be granted to subordinated groups, a matter historically relegated to the latter clause.97Yoshino, supra note 93, at 17179 (describing Obergefell as introducing an antisubordination liberty doctrine). ". Moreover, it is also because of genetic reasons. The article then gets reviewed by a more senior editorial member. Of course, we have by now established that more than half the nation prohibits or severely restricts cousin marriage, a percentage that cannot accurately be called a handful. See supra Section I.B. . That discrepancyprohibiting marriage but allowing cohabitationmotivated the Board of Immigration Appeals in Matter of Hirabayashi to conclude the jurisdiction in question could not claim any powerful social good was being advanced by its marriage prohibition.26510 I. for Biotechnology Info., https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK459183 [https://perma.cc/L356-DACZ] (noting that these disorders can be inherited as both autosomal recessive mutations or as autosomal dominant and X-linked mutations). Only 21 states in America allow first cousins to be married legally. These are the conditions in Wisconsin to marry first-cousins. Penal Code Ann. However, marriage between first cousins is only permitted in around half of the states in the United States. . Therefore, in order to avoid such a situation, couples should receive genetic counselling from a physician before they make a huge decision. first cousin. Del. Dark blue marks states, like California, where first-cousin marriage is legal. Rhode Islanders who share a grandparent and want to marry need not worry; the state allows first cousins, first cousins once-removed, half-cousins and cousins through adoption to wed, live together and have sexual relations. In Georgia, people are allowed to marry their first cousin. Yes, step-siblings are permitted to marry each other in most states and countries. The Court applied a mere reasonableness standard to hold that favored treatment of marriages between secondary beneficiaries does not violate the principle of equality embodied in the Due Process Clause of the Fifth Amendment. Id. The issue is health care, education, and access, not consanguinity. 3, 2002), https://www.nytimes.com/2002/04/03/health/no-genetic-reason-to-discourage-cousin-marriage-study-finds.html [https://perma.cc/GRX2-WHG4]. Analogously, communities that are historically highly endogamous, where there are a very small number of ancestors of the general population, have a statistically increased probability of sharing identical genesand the identical genetic mutations that come with it. The punishment depends on the laws of the states. at 375. They have either the same mother or the same father. Marriages between See Kuper, supra note 24, at 73233; see also Ottenheimer, supra note 19, at 15152; Bittles, Consanguinity in Context, supra note 25, at 5873; see generally supra Section I.A.1. Code Ann. and Obergefell287Obergefell v. Hodges, 576 U.S. 644, 672 (2015) ([W]hen that sincere, personal opposition becomes enacted law and public policy, the necessary consequence is to put the imprimatur of the State itself on an exclusion that soon demeans or stigmatizes those whose own liberty is then denied.). Half-cousins, first cousins once-removed and cousins through adoption can also marry. Often, the recessive genes from the parents pass on to the offspring and manifest their genetic material. For instance, there is a one-in-two chance a child of partners who are both carriers of recessive genes of autosomal dominant disorders, like cystic fibrosis or Huntingtons disease, will manifest the disease. 20-2-101 (West 2021). Beginning in Loving, continuing in Zablocki, and pushing forward in Obergefell, the Court expressed that the right to marry inherently includes the freedom to follow ones personal path in exercising it.101Loving v. Virginia, 388 U.S. 1, 12 (1967) (The freedom to marry has long been recognized as one of the vital personal rights essential to the orderly pursuit of happiness by free men.); Goodridge v. Dept of Pub.

John H Francis Polytechnic High School Class Of 1969, Ps5 Party Chat Audio Through Tv, Morgan's Riflemen Flag, Exemple De Test De Recrutement Dans Une Banque+pdf, Can You Renew A Permit After Expiration California, Articles I